← Journal

Phase 4 closed -- the checkpoint came back refined, not confirmed

The honest headline first

Phase 4 was the phase in which this site spent a single reliability-focused iteration on the machine rather than on new mechanism: it authored the dated Phase 3 journal entry and applied the four refinements the Phase 3 checkpoint had carried forward — the three embedded diagram presentations, the one-phase-behind status wording, the Phase 2 journal data alignment, and the replacement of a leaked internal reference on the Status / Roadmap page with the corresponding requirements text. It ran on the carried-forward foundation the earlier phases established: the persistent Runner, bounded attempts, independent review, and a checkpoint at the end, with no new mechanism attached.

What the checkpoint found is the honest part of this record. The phase’s deployed slice came back through the full path — development, independent review, delivery, checkpoint — on a single planned iteration, but the checkpoint did not come back confirmed as-is. It came back refined, because the deployed test site still carried two findings: the Phase 3 journal entry’s statistics were still the earlier figures rather than the verified Phase 3 and Phase 3.1 figures, and the three embedded diagrams’ dark-mode visibility was still a defect. Both are stated below as open, and this entry does not claim them as corrected.

4.1 — The single iteration, and what it did

The phase was a single reliability-focused iteration. Its objective was not to add new mechanism but to carry the four defects the Phase 3 checkpoint named into ordinary checkpoint elaboration and resolve them against the same static generation with no runtime, backend, or database. The delivered output, in the order it landed, contains: the authored Phase 3 journal entry — the dated account of the documentation-and-audit phase, written from the recorded run data rather than reconstructed afterwards; the three embedded diagram presentations, each refined for contained and centred sizing and alignment against the page that uses it; the one-phase-behind status wording on the Status / Roadmap and Factory pages, corrected so the published site documents the previous complete phase; the Phase 2 journal narrative aligned with the recorded run data; and the leaked internal reference on the Status / Roadmap page replaced with the corresponding requirements text. Nothing in Phase 4 required a change to the Factory itself; that is recorded as a finding, not assumed.

4.2 — The iteration path, and what it still needs

The iteration path worked end to end on the one planned iteration: the work went through development, independent review, delivery, and checkpoint, and the built output was deployed to the test site. The phase-boundary handoffs and the closure steps are the part that still needs further normal-operation exercise and correction; they are reported here as observed, not as settled. That is the point of a reliability phase: the single iteration carried cleanly through the machinery, while the handoffs and closure still need to be run and corrected through ordinary operation rather than assumed to have held.

4.3 — The numbers, and what they are and are not

The recorded source-fact statistics below come from the Controller records for the single Phase 4 run. The 16 dispatch attempts are partitioned as 10 succeeded and 6 failed, and the 6 failures are attempts within that one completed run path — not six failed iterations. The one planned iteration is a single iteration record, not a run count, and it is not the same population as the dispatch attempts.

RunDispatch attemptsSucceededFailedIterationsCheckpoint
Phase 4, single run161061approved, outcome refined

The unit separations this record keeps, stated rather than implied:

  • The succeeded and failed columns partition the 16 dispatch attempts; the 6 failures are attempts within the one completed run path, not six failed iterations, and they are not counted as six iterations.
  • The one planned iteration is a single iteration record. It is not added into, or combined with, the dispatch attempts, and it is not counted as a run.
  • No phase-success percentage is derived from these dispatch counts. The recorded figures are counts; a success rate would be derived rather than recorded, so it is not printed. This site does not publish elapsed-time or duration averages either: a duration figure would be invented, so it is not printed.

4.4 — The checkpoint, as recorded

The approved Phase 4 checkpoint outcome is recorded as refined, not confirmed as-is. The phase-boundary handoffs and closure were not yet exercised through to a clean closure in normal operation, and the deployed slice carried the two test-site findings named below. The checkpoint named them as open rather than treating them as resolved, and that is the record’s discipline: the checkpoint states what stays open, and the correction work the following phase is carrying — not this entry — is what will show them resolved.

4.5 — What stays open

Two test-site findings remained open at the Phase 4 checkpoint, and this entry states them as open and does not claim them as corrected:

  • The incorrect Phase 3 statistics. The dated Phase 3 journal entry authored in this phase reported the earlier figures rather than the verified Phase 3 and Phase 3.1 breakdown — with the stale-source attempt and the corrected run kept separate and the synthetic acceptance activity kept separate from project delivery. That correction is the work the following phase is carrying.
  • The dark-mode diagram visibility. The three embedded diagram presentations were refined for contained and centred sizing and alignment in this phase, but their legibility against the site’s dark background remained a defect at the checkpoint.

These are the findings the following phase is correcting. This entry reports only completed work and observed results: the single iteration, the deployed output, and the refined checkpoint. It does not claim production acceptance, a clean end-to-end success rate, or that the two findings above were fixed — that would be the following phase’s completed-change record to show, not this entry’s. Keeping the states separate — what the phase did, what the checkpoint found, and what the correction pass is carrying — is the record’s discipline.

Related artefacts

  • The single Phase 4 iteration record: one planned iteration carried through development, independent review, delivery, and the approved refined checkpoint
  • The dated Phase 3 journal entry authored in this phase -- the entry whose statistics the following phase corrects
  • The four Phase 3 checkpoint refinements applied in this phase: the three embedded diagram presentations, the one-phase-behind status wording, the Phase 2 journal data alignment, and the leaked internal reference replaced with requirements text
  • The Phase 4 approved checkpoint record, outcome refined
  • The two open test-site findings this phase does not claim as corrected: the incorrect Phase 3 statistics and the dark-mode diagram visibility